Creepy Cocktails to Pair with Your Favorite Halloween Candy

By: Caitlin Heikkila

Photo by: Stephen Murello

Stephen Murello

The best Halloween parties have three things in common: killer costumes, candy galore and plenty of cocktails to keep things interesting.

Before you go mixing up a truly spooky jungle juice, try these bewitching candy and cocktail pairings.

Pair Almond Joy with a Black Devil Martini

A simple mix of spiced rum and vermouth with a garnish of black olives, the Black Devil Martini (pictured above)  is a savory sipper. Since spicy rum and sweet coconut are a time-honored classic, try pairing this drink with an Almond Joy bar. The salty nuts and briny olives make a great match, too.

Pair Candy Corn with Witches Brew

This spellbinding sweet, tart Witches Brew combines pineapple and cranberry juices, bubbly soda and a splash of coconut rum. Color- and sugar-wise, it's great with candy corn.

Photo by: Stephen Murello

Stephen Murello

Pair Starbursts with Zombie Gut Punch

Party girls Alie and Georgia created a Halloween punch that is unnaturally smooth and boozy. Sweet blood-orange juice, cherry soda and grenadine add tartness and body to vodka, triple sec and bitters for a zombie-inspired sip that's awesome with fruity chews, like orange or red Starbursts.

Photo by: Shane Redsar ©Shane Redsar

Shane Redsar, Shane Redsar

Pair Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups with Cemetery Slime Punch

Think of Cemetery Slime Punch as a spookier Root Beer Float. The recipe suggests vanilla and chocolate frozen yogurt for a frothy, creamy, fizzy treat. Cut the sweetness with a salty Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup.

Photo by: Stephen Murello

Stephen Murello

Pair Twix with Vampire Cocktail

Have a sweet tooth and a lust for blood? Go for a Vampire Cocktail with vanilla ice cream, white crème de cacao, triple sec and “bloody” grenadine. Twix bars are both a cookie AND a candy, which gives this pairing an essence of cookies and cream.

Photo by: Stephen Murello

Stephen Murello

More Halloween Ideas from Friends + Family:
Weelicious: Cookie Dough Bites

Elephants and the Coconut Trees: Halloween-Themed Appetizer: Beet and Cucumber Rolls

Big Girls, Small Kitchen: Olive Oil-Maple Granola Walnuts

Red or Green: Spicy Chard Chips
Dishing With Divya: Egg Puffs
Keep Reading

Next Up

6 Halloween Movie and Food Pairings for a Spooktacular Party

Get Halloween food and movie pairing ideas for Hocus Pocus, The Nightmare Before Christmas and more.

Party in Five: Voodoo-Themed Adults' Halloween Cocktail Party

Get Halloween party recipes, decorating ideas and printable invitations for an adults-only, voodoo-themed cocktail party from Cooking Channel.

Hocus Pocus Halloween Party Menu

Watch Hocus Pocus and make these Halloween recipes. We've got the Hocus Pocus party recipes to knock your friends off their broomsticks (or vacuum cleaners).

Fall Fest: Caramel Apples for Halloween

Happy Halloween! You might be full of mini candy bars already but since they are mainly a crispy fruit, there's always room for candy-coated apples.

On TV

Pick a Side!

The Snackdown

In our new animated series, we debate the most-pressing food matters of our time, like is cereal a soup?

So Much Pretty Food Here