The Great Peanut Butter Debate: Creamy or Chunky?

By: Michelle Buffardi
It's National Peanut Butter Lovers Day. Set down your afternoon snack for a second and consider your preference for one of the most nostalgic foods you're still in love with: the PB&J. Even with this, the world's simplest sandwich, there are rules. They're strict and vary with individual tastes, but these rules are undeniable and unbreakable when constructing a sandwich. Plain bread or toast? Strawberry jelly or grape? Do you use one knife for the peanut butter and another one for the jelly, or the same knife for both? Is it ok to lick the knife? Do you spread  topping on each slice then smoosh together, or dribble the jelly on top of the peanut butter? And most importantly, do you prefer creamy peanut butter or chunky?
The debate exists whether you're loyal to a certain brand, and even if you favor natural butters, which are naturally grainier, those come in chunky or smooth too. But of course peanut butter is more than a sandwich spread. So if you're cooking with the stuff, do you change your loyalty? If you use strictly creamy in your sandwich, would you consider a chunkier cookie?

Check out our best peanut butter recipes — sweet and savory:

So is there room in your cupboard for both chunky and creamy peanut butter? Or do you favor one type in every recipe and sandwich you make?
More peanut butter:
Keep Reading

Next Up

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

Oreos form the crust in this creamy, no-bake peanut butter pie recipe from Zoe Francois.

Happy National Peanut Butter & Jelly Day

Celebrate with Cooking Channel's spicy adult version.

Thirsty Thursday: Peanut Butter and Jealous Much?

Alie and Georgia bring back the childhood favorite of peanut butter and jelly, reinvented as the perfect happy hour cocktail recipe.

31 Days of Cookies: Double Peanut Butter Cup Cookies

Chocolate-peanut butter lovers will rejoice over these cocoa-nut cookies studded with chocolate chips, peanut butter chips and chocolate-peanut butter cups.

Beat The Wheat: Chocolate Cake with Peanut Butter Icing


A recipe for gluten-free Hershey's chocolate cake with peanut-butter frosting.

On TV

So Much Pretty Food Here