Buttermilk Pie

By: Nealey Dozier
Buttermilk Pie

My boyfriend’s mother is a one-woman Southern show. Seriously, she does it all – and has three well-rounded sons to prove it. Feeding those growing boys (and a loving husband) couldn’t have been easy, but she makes it look like a piece of cake. I’ve got a lot to learn. Fortunately, she's given me a good start: I’ve inherited her tattered purple recipe folder with all the secrets of her Southern kitchen.

The woman has a lot of delicious traditions, but one of my favorites is her gift of buttermilk pie. Every Christmas, she bakes off hundreds (thousands!) of her famous pies to give to her friends and loved ones. Even the mailman and trash guys eagerly await their annual treat. I can only hope that one day I’ll have a signature dessert as anticipated as hers.

So what exactly is buttermilk pie? It’s really just a traditional chess pie (eggs, sugar, butter) spiked with a tangy hit of buttermilk to add a little somethin’ special. Southerners are famous for their ability to make sinfully rich baked goods with only ingredients from the pantry, and this classic pie is no exception. Now that I’ve mastered the recipe, I won’t have to wait until December to get my fill. Sometimes a gift of food just tastes better when you make it yourself.

Nealey's Buttermilk Pie
Buttermilk Pie

Prep time: 10 minutes
Total time: 1 hour and 10 minutes
Yields: 8 – 10 slices
Ingredients
1 cup sugar
2 tablespoons flour
Pinch of salt
1 stick unsalted butter, melted and cooled
3 eggs
1 cup buttermilk
1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
1 unbaked piecrust, homemade or store bought
Directions
  • Preheat oven to 325 degrees F. Combine flour, sugar, and salt in a medium bowl.
  • In a large mixing bowl, beat together butter and eggs until well combined. Add buttermilk and vanilla and continue mixing. Gradually add flour mixture until all of the ingredients are incorporated.
  • Pour the filling into the piecrust and bake for one hour. The pie should be completely set and the top a light golden brown. Allow to cool completely before serving. Dust with powdered sugar, if desired.

More Southern Eats From Nealey

Nealey moved from Alabama to the West Coast to follow her dreams, only to realize once there how much she missed good ol’ country cooking.  So she took to the kitchen and began re-creating the dishes of her past, but this time without any help from a can. What started out as a hobby turned into an obsession, so she quit her day job to pursue cooking – and eating – fulltime. Dixie Caviar is where you can follow her pursuits of all things Southern.

Next Up

Easy Rhubarb-Cherry Pie

Learn how to make an easy rhubarb pie with this recipe and step-by-step instructions from Cooking Channel.

Easy as Pie: Apple Galette

A galette is a French tart, or simply a pie with no plate. This Apple Galette recipe is "easier than pie", with no fancy fluting or lattice top crust to worry about.

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

Oreos form the crust in this creamy, no-bake peanut butter pie recipe from Zoe Francois.

Sweet Potato Casserole Pie with Marshmallow Praline Topping

Turn sweet potato casserole into a pie recipe this Thanksgiving with this southern twist from Cooking Channel.

Going Ape for Apricot Preserves

Take advantage of stone fruit season with Sean Timberlake's apricot jam recipe. Apricots don’t need much, but their flavor takes nicely to a little spice.

Pescado en Salsa Verde

A staple in our Cuban house growing up, these buttery white fish fillets are drenched in parsley sauce then baked off with slices of potatoes.

Super Food Nerds: Make Your Own Kimchi

Make kimchi from scratch with this recipe and cooking tips from Cooking Channel.

On TV

So Much Pretty Food Here