Who Makes the Best Lobster Roll in the Country?

By: Roberto Ferdman

Lobster rolls can make for quite a testy conversation topic. Some like theirs smeared in mayo, while others prefer a generous drizzle of butter. There are those who swear by no-frills hot dog buns, and those who fancy something a bit more adventurous, like a buttery brioche.

With all that in mind, and some serious street cred at stake, 18 of the country's top lobster rolls went claw to claw in Tasting Table's annual Lobster Roll Rumble event last Thursday in New York City. We got our hands on a ticket, and then couldn't keep them off all the irresistible rolls vying for the first place prize.

Check out our favorite bites from last week's lobster roll claw-off.

When it came to presentation, NYC's Ditch Plains made sure not to be outdone. Their miniature rolls sat atop a table laden with colorful salt water taffy — a clever shout out to the (un)official lobster state of Maine. But their display offered far more than just eye candy. Their entry was outstanding: buttered, grilled potato rolls, stuffed with lobster meat mixed with garlic aioli, scallions, celery, tarragon, parsley and Old Bay seasoning.

Lobster roll powerhouse Red Hook Lobster Pound put forth a roll as pretty as it was well-prepared. It was a shout-out to east coast purists, featuring large chunks of Maine lobster, lightly dressed in lemon mayo, and sandwiched into a classic hot dog bun.

Mary's Fish Camp offered up a glorious (and gluttonous) counterpart to the otherwise lighter fare. Chunks of fresh lobster meat from Spruce Head, Maine, was drenched in tangy, lemon mayo, sprinkled with salt and pepper, garnished with tiny scallion rounds and lain atop a butter-soaked hot dog bun.

When all was said and done, local lobster roll favorite and reigning champ Luke's Lobster took home first place. Their mouth-watering roll came packed with tons of chilled Maine lobster, and was dressed up with a touch of mayo, drizzle of butter, and sprinkling of owner Luke Holden's homemade seasoning. Piled high on a butter-soaked hot dog bun, it won over our hearts (and stomachs), too — it was the best bite we had all evening.

Stoked about summer seafood? So is Seafoodie Ben Sargent, and he's traveling the country exploring local fishing culture and wide open waters, and finding lots of amazing seafood on the all new Cooking Channel show, Hook, Line and Dinner.

Craving something other than seafood? Check out Cooking Channel's Guide to Summer Grilling:

Next Up

What Makes a College Eat the Best?

After some careful analysis (and sampling of the dishes) we identified these key elements when cooking up a Best College Eat.

Road Trip: Lobster Rolls

Just in time for the height of summer, here are some of the best lobster rolls within 120 miles on NYC.

The Best Hotel Desserts

Oyster.com has dug into some of the most unique, mouth-watering desserts at hotels across the country.

The Best Seafood in the South

Charleston is a town steeped in history. But in the modern era, Charleston has become a tourist town where you can find some of the best seafood in the country.

The Best Hotel Bar Cocktails

Check out five of our favorite cocktails from hotel bars around the world. If you can't make the trip, make them at home -- we got the recipes. Either way, these drinks won’t disappoint.

The Best Labor Day Food

Get Cooking Channel's recipes and tips to make the most of the last drops of summer.


Unwrapped 2.0

7:30am | 6:30c

Unwrapped 2.0

8:30am | 7:30c

Unwrapped 2.0

9:30am | 8:30c

Food Truck Nation

12:30pm | 11:30c

Food: Fact or Fiction?

1:30pm | 12:30c

Good Eats

3pm | 2c

Good Eats

3:30pm | 2:30c

Good Eats

4pm | 3c

Good Eats

4:30pm | 3:30c

Good Eats

5pm | 4c

Good Eats

5:30pm | 4:30c

Man Fire Food

6:30pm | 5:30c

Man Fire Food

7:30pm | 6:30c
On Tonight
On Tonight

BBQ Pitmasters

8pm | 7c

Fire Masters

10pm | 9c

BBQ Pitmasters

12am | 11c
What's Hot
What's Hot

The Best Thing I Ever Ate

New Episodes Mondays 9|8c

So Much Pretty Food Here