Crab Feast Food Fight: Maryland vs. Louisiana

By: Sara Levine

I grew up in Maryland. My husband-to-be hails from Louisiana. Though our hometowns were quite different, one thing unites both states: seafood. We both grew up digging into hard-shell crabs on tables spread with butcher paper, learning as young tykes how to extract as much meat as possible from each one. But that’s where the seafood similarity ends. We happened to visit both families on back-to-back weekends this summer, which presented the perfect opportunity for a regional crab smackdown.

The first time my fiancé experienced a Maryland crab feast, he was confused. “What are these for?” he asked, holding up a small wooden mallet. That’s what we Chesapeake Bay devotees use to crack crabs, along with a pointy-ended plastic knife to help get the meat out of every nook and cranny. In Louisiana, they use metal crackers. In my neck of the woods, those are exclusively for lobster and would never grace the table at a crab feast.

Then there’s the question of seasoning. Old Bay is Maryland’s pride and joy. A generous amount of this regional seasoning is heaped over any pile of freshly boiled crabs, and it also seasons the cooking water. While heavy-handed seasoning is a trademark of Louisiana cuisine, strangely enough, their crabs are not as flavorful. They’re cooked in water with special “seafood boil” seasoning mix, but nothing is dumped on top of the cooked crabs like I’m used to. Thus, the Louisiana seafood boil is a little less messy.

What about the quality of the crabs themselves? I find the Maryland blue crab meat a little sweeter, more delicate. But as my fiancé would counter — and unfortunately, he’s right — many of the crabs served up in Maryland these days come from Louisiana. If you’re eating crabs on the Chesapeake in the off-season, chances are they didn’t swim in the water you’re looking at, but came from the Gulf of Mexico.

Next consideration: What’s on the seafood spread in addition to crabs? Peel-and-eat shrimp are common in both locations. Corn on the cob is, too. But in Louisiana you get crawfish — pounds and pounds of the little guys. This forgives the lack of Old Bay in my book — once I got the technique down, I became an addict. For more on that, check out our Southern expert Nealey Dozier’s post on How to Host a Crawfish Boil.

Where do your crab loyalties lie?
Keep Reading

Next Up

Food Fight -- Magic Mike vs. Juicy Lucy

Magic Mike's Channing Tatum takes on Cooking Channel's Juicy Lucy Burger Recipe. Get the burger recipes and tips to handle the heat.

Food Fight - Hunger Games Edition: Peeta Vs. Pita

Peeta Mellark versus Pita bread in the Ultimate Hunger Games-inspired Food Fight on CookingChannelTV.com

Best Cinematic Food Fight Scenes

Belly up and feast on these celluloid indulgences: Cooking Channel's top picks for (mostly vintage) movie food fight scenes.

Friday Food Fight: Corn-Tomato Salad

Who makes the better corn salad recipe, Mark Bittman or Kelsey Nixon? Weigh on at CookingChannelTV.com.

Watch Haylie Duff vs. Food on Haylie's America

Watch a preview of Haylie Duff's Cooking Channel show Haylie's America to see what happens during her Cheat Day episode.

NYC Food Trucks vs. Midtown Parking Ban

New York City food trucks are feeling the pinch after a court ruling this year began enforcing a 1965 law that prohibits vending from metered parking spots.

Chuck vs. Roger: Cocktail Duel

Chuck Hughes vs. Roger Mooking, Cocktail Edition. Who is the king of mixology?

The Clash of the 'Duckens: Turducken vs. Veggieducken

Get the recipe for the classic turducken and a new vegetarian version with squash, leek and potatoes.

On TV

Tia Mowry at Home

7:30am | 6:30c

Tia Mowry at Home

8:30am | 7:30c

Tia Mowry at Home

9:30am | 8:30c

Brunch at Bobby's

10:30am | 9:30c

Brunch at Bobby's

11:30am | 10:30c

Cheap Eats

12pm | 11c

Cheap Eats

12:30pm | 11:30c

Cheap Eats

1pm | 12c

Good Eats

2pm | 1c

Good Eats

2:30pm | 1:30c
On Tonight
On Tonight

Good Eats

8pm | 7c

Good Eats

8:30pm | 7:30c

Good Eats: Reloaded

9:30pm | 8:30c

Good Eats

10pm | 9c

Good Eats

10:30pm | 9:30c

Good Eats

11:30pm | 10:30c

Good Eats

12am | 11c

Good Eats

12:30am | 11:30c

Good Eats: Reloaded

1:30am | 12:30c

Good Eats

2am | 1c

Good Eats

2:30am | 1:30c

Good Eats

3:30am | 2:30c
What's Hot
What's Hot

Cheap Eats

So Much Pretty Food Here