Yellow Mustard BBQ Sauce, and Changing My Mind About Mustard

By: Sarah Copeland

Not long after I first got married, my new husband returned from his inaugural grocery duties with a dinosaur-size bottle of yellow mustard.

“Yellow mustard?” I stammered. What in the world would I ever do with it all? It was exactly the kind of condiment that I thought had no place in my kitchen. If food snobbery is a disease, I’m as afflicted as anyone. I was a Dijon girl all the way. Whole grain. Or spicy brown. Artisan. Local if possible. Nothing that came in a gigantic squeeze bottle. But to humor him, I made a batch of homemade German pretzels, which was good for about a quarter cup of consumption. Flash forward three years, and that mustard would still be hanging around the back shelf waiting for its next booking.

But I was wrong about yellow mustard. Case in point: Vince Camillo’s South Carolina Style BBQ Sauce, which was undeniably delicious. As Heather Ramsdell put it when we circled in the test kitchen around some mustard-smothered chicken legs, “You don’t wonder if that’s good, you just know it.” They were assertive, spicy, electrically good. That night I took the sauce home and smothered it on some line-caught halibut which I stuffed into toasted tortillas with shaved radish. And I’ve been thinking about it ever since.

That’s the thing about bbq sauce. Take something everyday, like tomato paste or molasses, malt vinegar or plain old yellow mustard and turn it into something that lingers in the mind. You could throw in something surprising, like yuzu or bonito flakes, and fancy it up to your liking. Or you can simply stir together the basics, in just the proportions you like, and smoother it all over that thing you love — be it pork, chicken, fish, beef or seitan. Smother, smother away.

More BBQ on Cooking Channel

Photos and post by Sarah Copeland. Recipe by Vincent Camillo.

Sarah Copeland is a food person and recently-converted yellow mustard fan. Follow along with Sarah on her blog,, and be sure to check out her first cookbook, The Newlywed Cookbook.

Keep Reading

Next Up

Mustard That Passes Muster

Make mustard that tastes much more pungeant and fresh with this homemade dijon mustard recipe from Cooking Channel.

The Final Four: Game-Changing Flavors

As the clock counts down to the Final Four games of March Madness this weekend, it’s time to turn your attention to the spread … the snack spread, that is.

28 Life-Changing Chicken Recipes

Find new twists on easy chicken dinner recipes, with new spices and creative ideas from Cooking Channel chefs.

The Mind of a Pizza Master

On Cooking Channel's Pizza Masters, Sal Basille and Francis Garcia, owners of NYC's Artichoke Basille's Pizza, embark on a  mouthwatering exploration of Italian food across the country. We sat with the two pizza aficionados to find out more about running a pizza empire and the best slices in the world.

White BBQ Sauce: The Next Big Trend in Barbecue

Restaurants across the country are starting to serve Alabama's old secret sauce. Find out what makes it so special and get the recipe.

SoundBites: Music, Food and Change

Cooking Channel visits Soundbites, DC Central Kitchen's Festival for Music, Food and Change. Get the best bites, recipes from local restaurants and behind-the-scenes photos.

Traveling with Kiddos Without Losing Your Mind

New mom Haylie Duff spends her fair share of time on airplanes, and this is how she maintains her sanity while traveling with kids


So Much Pretty Food Here