The Secret(s) to Ben Sargent's Famous Lobster Roll

By: Michelle Buffardi
lobster roll

For about a year, Ben Sargent sold lobster rolls out of his Greenpoint, Brooklyn apartment. He was dealing 150 buttery, succulent, fresh-from-the-sea sandwiches per night -- illegally. Then, just as he was about to go legit, while he was away taping a pilot for a show on seafood for Cooking Channel, his underground lobster pound was shut down by the city of New York. Ben Sargent and his lobster roll-slinging alter-ego Dr. Klaw were lobster roll pushers no more.

Now that he's legit, the host of Hook, Line & Dinner will no sooner share his top-secret lobster roll recipe than he would eat imitation crab meat. It just won't happen.

But he did walk us through the process at a recent visit to the Cooking Channel and Food Network test kitchens, and smart cooks just might catch on . . .

Ben starts with a fresh, live lobster -- the best he can get. He steams it in 2 inches of water seasoned with onion, peppercorns, old bay and salt -- enough so that it tastes like the ocean the clawed creature, the one that's about to become a sandwich, once swam in. The lobster gets steamed till it's just cooked, even slightly undercooked, about 8-10 minutes per lobster. Each lobster cooked in the water will be more flavorful than the last, since the lobsters will add flavor to the spiced water as they cook.

Once the lobster is moments from fully cooking  through, Ben removes it from its steamy bath and plunges it into an ice bath. Once it's cool enough to break down, he removes the lobster meat from the shell (saving the shells for stock, of course) and mixes it with a bit of mayonnaise -- not enough to overpower the meat, this shouldn't look like deli tuna salad -- just enough to give it some more moisture and flavor.

lobster removed from shell

Then, in a step that ensures his roll is and always will be the best lobster roll in town, he throws the mayo-coated lobster onto a hot griddle or skillet till the lobster is cooked through, and a pink sauce forms from the lobster and mayonnaise. The hot lobster goes back into the bowl while he toasts the bun -- the lobster shouldn't be piping hot when it's served.

lobster cooking on griddle

As for the bun,  Ben prefers the top-loaded kind. So he gets one of those and brushes it with some butter that's been melted with wine and garlic, and toasts it till it's golden brown. He loads the warm lobster mixture into the hot, buttery, toasty bun, and brushes the meat with more of the melted butter.

toasted bun

Then it must be devoured, unadorned. No celery, no bacon, no dill or tarragon and certainly no lettuce. Lettuce is to a lobster roll what kryptonite is to Superman. Or like what the NYC Department of Health is to Dr. Klaw.

ben sargent eating lobster roll
Recipes and More from Ben Sargent and Hook, Line & Dinner:

Next Up

Road Trip: Lobster Rolls

Just in time for the height of summer, here are some of the best lobster rolls within 120 miles on NYC.

Watch Bobby Flay Reveal the Secret to Perfect Eggs

We caught up with Brunch @ Bobby's host Bobby Flay to ask him why breakfast is the most important meal of the day, how to make scrambled eggs awesome and how to take pancakes to the next level.

Study Shows Frog Slime is the Secret to Saving Spoiled Milk

Scientists from Moscow State University have discovered that frog skin secretions help milk from going bad.

Who Makes the Best Lobster Roll in the Country?

Where can you find the best lobster roll in the country? From San Francisco to NYC and everywhere in between, here are the top lobster rolls around.

On TV

Unwrapped 2.0

7:30am | 6:30c

Food: Fact or Fiction?

10:30am | 9:30c

Good Eats

11am | 10c

Good Eats

11:30am | 10:30c

Good Eats: Reloaded

12:30pm | 11:30c

Good Eats: Reloaded

1:30pm | 12:30c

Man Fire Food

5:30pm | 4:30c

Man Fire Food

6:30pm | 5:30c

Man v. Food

7pm | 6c

Man v. Food

7:30pm | 6:30c
On Tonight
On Tonight

Man v. Food

8pm | 7c

Man v. Food

8:30pm | 7:30c

Man v. Food

9pm | 8c

Man v. Food

9:30pm | 8:30c

Eddie Eats America

10:30pm | 9:30c

Burgers, Brew & 'Que

11:30pm | 10:30c

Man v. Food

12am | 11c

Man v. Food

12:30am | 11:30c

Man v. Food

1am | 12c

Man v. Food

1:30am | 12:30c

Eddie Eats America

2:30am | 1:30c

Burgers, Brew & 'Que

3:30am | 2:30c
What's Hot
What's Hot

The Best Thing I Ever Ate

Sundays 10|9c

So Much Pretty Food Here