Should You Stuff the Thanksgiving Turkey?

Cooking Channel culinary experts hash out the great stuffing debate: Is it better to stuff the turkey or serve the dressing on the side?

Turkey with Stuffing

Photo by: Tara Donne ©Tara Donne

Tara Donne, Tara Donne

The distinction between stuffing and dressing, in spite of ongoing debates about bread bases and mix-ins, can be answered by one simple question: Where does the stuffing go? It's either roasted in the turkey (in which case it's called "stuffing"), or it is cooked in a separate dish (and is called "dressing").

There are pros and cons to both cooking styles. The primary advantages to in-bird stuffing are that it's unbelievably moist and looks super-Thanksgiving-y, but to be safe (with the raw eggs in the stuffing and the raw turkey touching it), you need to cook it to 165 degrees F, which means the bird's going to have to cook to an even higher temperature, which means a potentially dry bird.

If you cook the stuffing outside the turkey, first of all, it's no longer "stuffing" — it's "dressing." Both it and the turkey will cook more reliably, and you can fill the inside of the turkey (loosely) with aromatics if you're going for that Thanksgiving-y turkey-cornucopia look. Also, if you're planning on frying your turkey, or spatchcocking it, you definitely have to cook the stuffing outside the turkey.

But how do you reconcile an evenly cooked bird with not-as-moist dressing? The answer, readers, is turkey stock. Have a little extra stock on hand and drizzle it generously over the dressing before baking. Voila: moist dressing, no turkey cavity required.

Keep Reading

Next Up

Top 5 Thanksgiving Food Safety Tips

Abide by these food safety rules for peace of mind during Thanksgiving, from prepping the feast to packing up the leftovers.

Thanksgiving Turkey Buying Guide

Everything you need to know to pick out the perfect turkey for your Thanksgiving feast

No-Beef Burger Recipes

Get great non-beef burger recipes and tips from Kelsey Nixon, Rachael Ray and more using mushrooms, chicken, turkey and tuna on Cooking Channel.

5 Tips for Better Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

It's hard to improve upon the classic grilled cheese recipe, but we thought we'd give it a try. Here are three tips for upgrading your grilled cheese sandwich, plus a few new recipes to try out.

Top 10 Tips: How to Cook a Turkey

Serve your best bird yet — and make the turkey the centerpiece of your Thanksgiving table — with our tried-and-true top 10 turkey tips.

Thanksgiving Turkey Fixes

Hit a snag with your turkey? Don't reach for the takeout menu! Here are 5 ways to fix common turkey mishaps.

Fixes & Help for Thanksgiving Disasters

Think Thanksgiving's ruined? Fret not! We've got five quick fixes for any sort of cooking conundrum.

Make Your Own Gift Popcorn Tin

Fill a festive tin with a sweet and salty popcorn mix for an easier-than-it-looks homemade gift.

Feeding Guests During the Thanksgiving Holiday

Some smart preparation makes feeding your Thanksgiving houseguests a cinch — even if they're staying the whole holiday weekend.

How to Sharpen Your Garbage Disposal Blades

Here's a safe and easy trick to sharpen your garbage disposal blades.

On TV

So Much Pretty Food Here