Thanksgiving Turkey Buying Guide

Everything you need to know to pick out the perfect turkey for your Thanksgiving feast
Turkeys in winter field


Turkeys in winter field

Photo by: Maxim Petrichuk

Maxim Petrichuk

Turkeys in winter field

When you set out to buy a turkey, plan for one pound of meat per person; this means you'll have enough for everyone to take home leftovers. If you're hosting a sizeable crowd, you're better off roasting two smaller turkeys than a giant one –– bigger birds tend to be less flavorful. If your family loves turkey breast, roast an extra breast alongside your turkey so there's enough white meat for everyone.

Once you've determined how much turkey you'll need, you must decide what type of turkey suits your style:

These birds have access to the outside and the ability to move about a yard. Therefore, they have more muscle mass, which means more flavor.

No antibiotics, no growth enhancers and only organic feed, as well as access to the outdoors.

This can be put on a label if nothing artificial was added or used to process the meat.

Basted or Self-Basting
Whole birds that are injected with or marinated in a water/broth/fat/spice solution. They possess more moisture and less natural flavor.


Salted inside and out, and left to drain before soaking and washing. More dense, flavorful flesh; it shouldn’t be brined.


Refers to the breed of turkey. Old-fashioned varieties like Narragansett, Standard Bronze, Black Spanish and Bourbon Red have a lot of flavor and are smaller than popular standard breeds, with a more balanced dark-to-white ratio. Their meat is firmer and chewier.

Make sure you plan for plenty of cook time on the big day.

There are a few different ways you can roast your turkey. A spatchcocked turkey (cut to lie flat, with the backbone removed) will take about 8 minutes per pound at high heat (450 degrees F); on the other end of the spectrum, a stuffed bird will take about 20 minutes per pound at 325 degrees F.

Find a Thanksgiving turkey recipe that suits your style and fire away.

Next Up

Top 5 Thanksgiving Food Safety Tips

Abide by these food safety rules for peace of mind during Thanksgiving, from prepping the feast to packing up the leftovers.

Thanksgiving Turkey Fixes

Hit a snag with your turkey? Don't reach for the takeout menu! Here are 5 ways to fix common turkey mishaps.

Extreme Alternatives to Roasted Turkey for Thanksgiving

This Thanksgiving, why not try a new spin on the same old roasted turkey? The flavor in these recipes is definitely something to be thankful for.

Top 10 Tips: How to Cook a Turkey

Serve your best bird yet — and make the turkey the centerpiece of your Thanksgiving table — with our tried-and-true top 10 turkey tips.

How to Brine a Turkey

Learn the basics of brining and you'll be guaranteed the top turkey in town.

Fixes & Help for Thanksgiving Disasters

Think Thanksgiving's ruined? Fret not! We've got five quick fixes for any sort of cooking conundrum.

Thanksgiving Countdown: Schedule & Calendar

Count down to Thanksgiving with a checklist that will help you get your shopping and preparation in order.

Aarón Sanchez

The co-star of the hit series Heat Seekers and Food Network AND rsquo;s Chopped Aar AND oacute;n Sanchez is the executive chef and co-owner of Centrico Restaurant and Mestizo By Aar AND oacute;n S AND aacute;nchez. He is also the culinary visionary behind Tacombi Tacqueria and Crossroads at House of Blues.

So Much Pretty Food Here