Ben Sargent's Lobster Roll

There was a time when Hook, Line and Dinner star Ben Sargent was better known as Dr. Klaw: a Brooklyn, NY underground-lobster-roll-slinging hero. His buttery rolls were unadorned - no seasonings, no celery - and his recipe was top-secret. But we've extracted this perfect recipe from Ben's grippy claws and now happily share it with you. Though Ben hails from New York, the lobster roll is associated with New England states, and Maine in particular, where the ruby crustacean is most prevalent. One bite of Ben's famous roll and you'll never look at its weaker lettuce-topped counterpart again.
  • Level: Easy
  • Total: 35 min
  • Prep: 25 min
  • Cook: 10 min
  • Yield: 4 lobster rolls
Share This Recipe

Ingredients

3 tablespoons coarse sea salt

1 tablespoon whole black peppercorns

1 teaspoon seafood seasoning, such as Old Bay

1/2 yellow onion

4 lobsters (1 to 1 1/2 pounds each)

1 tablespoon mayonnaise

1 stick salted butter

Splash crisp white wine

2 cloves garlic, smashed

4 top-loading hot dog buns, such as Pepperidge Farm Classic Top-Sliced Hot Dog Buns

Directions

  1. Fill a stockpot with 1 to 2 inches of water and set over medium-high heat. Add the sea salt, peppercorns, seafood seasoning and onion. Once the water is boiling, add the lobsters. Cover the pot and steam the lobsters for 8 to 10 minutes. When finished, remove the lobsters and run under a blast of cold water.
  2. Carefully remove the meat from the shell, saving the juices, and coarsely cut into large chunks (usually, the meat from 1 lobster is good for 1 roll). Mix the lobster juices with the mayonnaise; it should be a wet, thin consistency. Lightly toss the lobster meat with the mayonnaise. 
  3. In a small saucepan over medium heat, melt the butter along with a splash of crisp white wine and the garlic. 
  4. Heat a large, flat grill pan or skillet over medium heat. Open the buns, brush the butter mixture on the insides and toast, buttered-side down, until golden brown, about 1 minute. 
  5. Place the lobster meat on some foil and gently heat on the grill as the buns are toasting. 
  6. Evenly divide the lobster meat among the rolls, brush the meat with some butter mixture and serve in paper boats.

Cook’s Note

Look for top-loading hot dog buns, not New England-style rolls with cut sides.

Fudge Factor

Over-the-Top-Delicious Treats to Satisfy Your Food Obsession

Are you infatuated with ice cream? Do you lust over lobster? Swoon at the sight of chocolate? Here's the best recipe for each food …

Review: Anthony Bourdain and Eric Ripert's Chocolate Bar Nov 16, 2012

Anthony Bourdain and Eric Ripert have teamed up with master chocolatier Christopher Curtin to create the "Good & Evil" chocolate b …

Train Frontman Pat Monahan's Dark Chocolate Obsession Feb 11, 2013

By: Cameron Curtis

Train frontman Pat Monahan, an avid chocolate lover, shared with us his top five reasons for eating dark chocolate.

The Craziest Chocolate Creations for American Chocolate Week Mar 17, 2013

It’s officially American Chocolate Week. Check out photos of mind-blowing chocolate creations.

Sifted: Plan-Ahead Valentine's Day Desserts Feb 6, 2013

By: Lauren Miyashiro

Get our take on the best in food news, recipes and more from around the web, including the best Valentine's Day recipes.

Chocolate Desserts

Indulge in our decadent chocolate desserts, from cookies and cakes to puddings, souffles and truffles.

Essentials: Chocolate Basics Sep 1, 2016

Satisfy that chocolate craving in your very own kitchen. All you need is baking chocolate and a little know-how. It also helps to …